A UK competition tribunal has dismissed a class action challenging Sony’s pricing practices on the PlayStation Store, according to Engadget’s November 17 report. The tribunal pointed to physical games and competing consoles as alternatives for customers buying PlayStation games.
The case was brought in 2022 by consumer advocate Alex Neill on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners. It sought £2 billion in damages over allegations that Sony’s control of its digital storefront allowed it to inflate prices.
A dispute over digital game prices
The claim challenged Sony’s 30 percent cut of PlayStation Store transactions and argued that games would cost about 20 percent less without the practices at issue. Engadget reports that eligible consumers could have received approximately £162 each if the action had succeeded.
Sony argued that accommodating third-party storefronts would be prohibitively expensive and would reduce security and performance. Those were the company’s arguments in the dispute, rather than independent findings about how alternative stores would operate.
Why the alternatives mattered
According to Engadget, the tribunal rejected both the claim that players were trapped in Sony’s ecosystem and the proposed 20 percent price reduction. It cited evidence that consumers would switch consoles in response to higher game prices.
The ruling also referenced Sony research indicating that the company risked losing business if its pricing was uncompetitive with Xbox.
For console players, the central issue is how competition is assessed when a platform controls its digital shop. In this case, the tribunal’s reasoning extended beyond that storefront to boxed games and rival hardware.
