Embark Studios has withdrawn a highlight video for The Finals’ APAC Closed Qualifier after commentators objected to their broadcast work being omitted in favor of the game’s AI-powered announcers. The studio also halted planned AMER and EMEA recaps using the same approach, according to IGN’s reporting.
The removed video featured Scotty and June, the shooter’s fictional commentary duo, narrating selected tournament moments ahead of The Grand Major. Embark told IGN that its team chose broadcast clips, wrote an original script and produced fresh commentary for the characters.
Studio acknowledges talent deserved recognition
Embark said it wanted to use familiar characters to introduce more players to the game’s competitive scene, but acknowledged that excluding the original broadcast talent was the wrong decision.
Oscar Lundberg, who works on competitive experience and community at Embark, also apologized publicly. He said the APAC video would not return in that form and that the studio was reconsidering all three regional recaps.
The criticism extends beyond whose voices appeared in the edit. Caster Proto / Kai alleged that the replacement commentary repeated things the human commentators had said. In his account to IGN, he described organizers selecting moments and preparing scripts, while saying the broadcast video itself had not been fed into the AI. Claims that the system was trained on the esports casters should therefore not be treated as established fact.
Casters seek stronger protections
Proto called for protections covering commentary and production teams, including contractual restrictions on generative AI use of their voices. Fellow caster Bluepanda told IGN the incident had left him ready to step away from the game and esports.
The dispute highlights a practical question for competitive gaming: how publishers credit and retain broadcast talent when repackaging tournament coverage through automated voices.
